At a Fire Island Christmas reunion party, three guys recall their three versions of the events that happened at Cherry Grove the previous summer.
Larry Page
John Carlo
Hugh Allen
Garry Hunt
Chris Michaels
Score: 5.9
Score: 7.2
Score: 5.4
Score: 1.0
Score: 6.0
Score: 1.0
Score: 6.3
Score: 5.3
